Destination Guide Refine search by clicking on selections below Cuisine American (2) Bagels & Donuts (1) Bakeries (1) Bars, Clubs + Pubs (4) Contemporary (4) French (2) Italian (5) Japanese (1) Mexican (1) Pizza (1) Sandwiches (3) Seafood (2) Southern + Soul (1) Thai (2) See fewer cuisine
 Title Keyword
| ||||||||||
| LIST VIEW | MAP VIEW | SORT BY NAME | STAR | PRICE |
| The American Hotel 45 Main St., Sag Harbor, NY 631.725.3535 |  |
main st sag harbor, ny the scenethe 155-year-old hotels four victorian dining rooms deliver on charm, with ornate chandeliers, languid ceiling fans, and nautical artifacts covering the walls. in spite of these trappings,... more
| REVIEWS (7) |
| Sen 23 Main St., Sag Harbor, NY 631.725.1774 | |
an attractive, black-clad staff serves sushi and other japanese dishes to the hip crowd that frequents this place. sashimi and rolls of all varieties are available; vegetable, noodle, and fresh-fish dishes help fill out ... more
| REVIEWS (6) |
| Peter Millers 16 N. Main St., Sag Harbor, NY 631.725.9100 | |
i had a wonderful experience at peter mullers, a locally owned hip restaurant/lounge. the ambiance was soft and invitinglots of soft golds and candlelight.the lounge, right behind the velvet curtains, offers a warm, groo... more
| REVIEWS (3) |
| Oasis Waterfront Restaurant and Bar 3253 Noyac Rd., Sag Harbor, NY 631.725.7110 | |
| New Paradise Cafe 126 Main St., Sag Harbor, NY 631.725.6080 | |
no doubt this is where locals and others like to come while in sag harbor. you will have to wait but no worries since they provide the entertainment of browsing the bookstore. prices are right and there is nothing wrong ... more
| REVIEWS (3) |
| Magnolia 29 Main St., Sag Harbor, NY 631.725.0101 | |
at this storefront restaurant, generous portions and gracious service satisfy the upscale crowd in search of southern cooking--fried chicken, popcorn shrimp, jambalaya. the bar is popular, too. ae, mc, v
| REVIEWS (3) |
| La Superica Main St. at Long Island Ave., Sag Harbor, NY 631.725.3388 | |
from the fresh lime juice in the margaritas to the fresh tuna in the tacos, the mexican offerings here are well prepared and tasty. traditional burritos and quesadillas are large, with many options for vegetarians. next ... more
| REVIEWS (1) |
| Jeff and Eddy's Seafood 62 Main St., Sag Harbor, NY 631.725.0055 | |
with leather booths, white-tiled walls, and vintage photographs, this lively seafood joint resembles an old-fashioned chowder house. its known for fresh local fish, simple preparations, and extensive raw bar, and theres ... more
| REVIEWS (4) |
| Il Capuccino 30 Madison St., Sag Harbor, NY 631.725.2747 | |
chianti bottles hang from the ceiling over tables draped in red-and-white-checked cloths. consistently good cooking and service make the three rooms of this italian family eatery a year-round favorite. the garlic bread a... more
| REVIEWS (3) |
| Harbor Delicatessen 111 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 631.725.7398 | |
|
|
 |